Rochester City Court Judge Caroline Morrison has recused herself from a case regarding the attack of an autistic teen, claiming her continued involvement may spark public perception of bias and confusion.
Morrison made her announcement in court Friday, after the accused, 57-year-old Martin MacDonald of Pittsford, pleaded not guilty to a second-degree harassment charge.
“I think it’s appropriate that this case start over with a new judge,” Morrison said.
The judge also issued an Order of Protection against MacDonald, prohibiting him from making any contact with the victim.
MacDonald turned himself in Thursday, after an incident last month when he allegedly shoved 15-year-old Chase Coleman, who is autistic and nonverbal, to the ground at Cobb’s Hill Park. The story has received national attention, and prompted calls of racism and conversations about inclusion. Coleman is African American.
Morrison initially refused to sign a warrant for MacDonald’s arrest. She clarified the move at the arraignment, stating she had requested more paperwork and further proof.
“For the record, I did not deny the arrest warrant nor did I dismiss the case,” Morrison said.
Second-degree harassment is a violation and the maximum jail sentence is 15 days.
Morrison said Judge Ellen Yacknin will preside over the case when MacDonald makes his next court appearance on Nov. 9.
