WXXI Local Stories
11:39 am
Thu October 17, 2013

New York's Top Court Backs An Exception To Miranda Rights

Credit npr.org

(AP)  New York's highest court says police can interrogate a suspect without reading their Miranda rights or providing a lawyer when they reasonably believe there's a serious, ongoing emergency. 

The Court of Appeals says the exception to a defendant's rights applies even when authorities don't know for certain a crime happened. 

The court on Thursday backed prosecutors' use of incriminating statements Scott Doll made after the February 2009 beating death of business partner Joseph Benaquist. 

A Genesee County deputy responding to an evening 911 call about a suspicious person found him walking on a roadway. 

Doll initially said wet blood on his clothes was from butchering deer. 

He asked for a lawyer and declined to take authorities to the deer. 

Doll, now 51, is serving 15 years to life in prison.